Profiling Excluders from German Casinos using Municipality Level Data

Main Article Content

Tanja Strohäker
Tilman Becker


Gambling is not a totally undisputed way to spend leisure time. While most people pursue their play instinct only from time to time, some happen to lose control over their urge and develop a problematic or even pathological gambling behavior. Getting excluded can be a way to regain control and minimize harm for affected gamblers. In comparison to the majority of other work dealing with this topic, not individual level information was used, but higher aggregated municipality level data. The goal of this paper was to analyze in what way sociodemographic factors and proximity measures can be used to explain the variation in the number of excluded gamblers across German communities. For that purpose, a unique dataset with 3,091 observations containing information about the number of excluders as well as census data and spatial information has been created. The method used for estimation of the effects was OLS. The results of the study suggested that excluders are more likely to be male, between 30 and 39 years old and less likely to be single. Due to flaws in the data, the other sociodemographic factors did not yield significant associations.  Additionally, the number of exclusions increases with close proximity to gambling establishments. The distance to the closest casino has a negative impact on exclusions. This is backed up by the finding that there are relatively more exclusions in communities where casinos are directly located.

Article Details



N Albers and L Hübl ‘Gambling Market and Individual Patterns of Gambling in Germany’ (1997) 13 Journal of Gambling Studies 2 pp 125-144

D Barth ‘Jahresreport 2015 der Glücksspielaufsichtsbehörden der Länder’ (2016) Retrieved December 20, 2016 from

A Blaszczynski, R Ladouceur and L Nower ‘Self-Exclusion: A proposed Gateway to Treatment Model’ (2007) 7 International Gambling Studies 1 pp 59-71

G Bondolfi, C Osiek and F Ferrero ‘Prevalence estimates of pathological gambling in Switzerland’ (2007) 101 Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 6 pp 473–475

E Botterill, P R Gill, S McLaren and R Gomez ‘Marital Status and Problem Gambling Among Australian Older Adults: The Mediating Role of Loneliness’ (2015) 32 Journal of Gambling Studies 3 pp 1027–1038

Bundesverband deutscher Spielbanken ‘Wirtschaftsdaten‘ (2015) Retrieved December 20, 2016, from

S Castrén, S Basnet, M Pankakoski, J-E Ronkainen, S Helakorpi, A Uutela, … R Ladouceur ‘An analysis of problem gambling among the Finnish working-age population: a population survey’ (2013) 13 BMC Public Health 1 pp 519

N Dowling, D Smith and T Thomas ‘Electronic gaming machines: are they the ‘crack-cocaine’ of gambling?’ (2005) 100 Addiction 1 pp 33–45

N Faregh and C Leth-Steensen ‘Reflections on the Voluntary Self-Exclusion of Gamblers and the Law-Suits against Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation’ (2009) 25 Journal of Gambling Studies 2 pp 131–138

W Feigelman, P H Kleinman, H R Lesieur, R B Millman and M L Lesser ‘Pathological gambling among methadone patients’ (1995) 39 Drug and Alcohol Dependence 2 pp 75–81

I Fiedler ‘Evaluierung des Sperrsystems in deutschen Spielbanken‘ (2015) 10 Zeitschrift Für Wett- Und Glücksspielrecht 03–04 pp 188–197

K G Götestam and A Johansson ‘Characteristics of gambling and problematic gambling in the Norwegian context: A DSM-IV-based telephone interview study’ (2003) 28 Addictive Behaviors 1 pp 189–197

G W Hall, N J Carriero, R Y Takushi, I D Montoya, K L Preston and D A Gorelick ‘Pathological Gambling Among Cocaine-Dependent Outpatients’ (2000) 157 American Journal of Psychiatry 7 pp 1127–1133

W Haß and P Lang ‘Glücksspielverhalten und Glücksspielsucht in Deutschland: Ergebnisse des Surveys 2015 und Trends‘ (2016) Köln: Forschungsbericht der BZgA

T Hayer and G Meyer (2011a) ‘Internet Self-Exclusion: Characteristics of Self-Excluded Gamblers and Preliminary Evidence for Its Effectiveness’ (2011a) 9 International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction 3 pp 296-307

T Hayer and G Meyer (2011b) ‘Self-Exclusion as a Harm Minimization Strategy: Evidence for the Casino Sector from Selected European Countries’ (2011b) 27 Journal of Gambling Studies 4 pp 685-700

L Hübl ‘Der Markt für Spielanken in Deutschland‘ in I. Gebhardt & S. M. Grüsser-Sinopoli (eds.) Glücksspiel in Deutschland - Ökonomie, Recht, Sucht (De Gruyter Recht, 2008) pp 93–113

A Johansson, J E Grant, S W Kim, B L Odlaug and K G Götestam ’Risk Factors for Problematic Gambling: A Critical Literature Review’ (2009) 25 Journal of Gambling Studies 1 pp 67–92

J M Kelly and A Igelman ‘Compulsive Gambling Litigation: Casinos and the Duty of Care’ (2009) 13 Gaming Law Review and Economics 5 pp 386–403

P Kielholz and D Ladewig Die Abhängigkeit von Drogen (München, dtv Wiss. Reihe 4134, 1973)

R A LaBrie, S E Nelson, D A LaPlante, A J Peller, G Caro, and H J Shaffer ‘Missouri Casino Self-Excluders: Distributions Across Time and Space’ (2007) 23 Journal of Gambling Studies 2 pp 231–243

R Ladouceur, C Jacques, I Giroux, F Ferland and J Leblond ‘Analysis of a Casino’s Self-Sxclusion Program’ (2000) 16 Journal of Gambling Studies 4 pp 453–460

R Ladouceur, C Sylvain and P Gosselin ‘Self-Exclusion Program: A Longitudinal Evaluation Study’ (2007) 23 Journal of Gambling Studies 1 pp 85–94

H R Lesieur and S B Blume ‘The South Oaks Gambling Screen (SOGS): a new instrument for the identification of pathological gamblers’ (1987) 144 American Journal of Psychiatry 9 pp 1184–1188

S Lischer, J Häfeli and S Villiger ‘Vulnerable Personengruppen im Glücksspielbereich‘ (2014) 9 Prävention und Gesundheitsförderung 1 pp 47–51

C Meyer, H-J Rumpf, A Kreuzer, S de Brito, S Glorius, C Jeske, … John, U. (2009) ‘Pathologisches Glücksspielen und Epidemiologie (PAGE): Entstehung, Komorbidität, Remission und Behandlung‘ Endbericht an das Hessische Ministerium des Innern und für Sport

G Meyer and T Hayer Die Effektivität der Spielersperre als Maßnahme des Spielerschutzes: eine empirische Untersuchung von gesperrten Spielern (Peter Lang, 2010)

F Napolitano ‘The Self-Exclusion Program: Legal and Clinical Considerations’ (2003) 19 Journal of Gambling Studies 3 pp 303–315

S E Nelson, J H Kleschinsky, R A LaBrie, S Kaplan and H J Shaffer ‘One Decade of Self Exclusion: Missouri Casino Self-Excluders Four to Ten Years after Enrollment’ (2010) 26 Journal of Gambling Studies 1 pp 129–144

N R Nowatzki and R J Williams ‘Casino self‐exclusion programmes: A review of the issues’ (2002) 2 International Gambling Studies 1 pp 3–25

L Nower and A Blaszczynski ‘Characteristics and Gender Differences Among Self-Excluded Casino Problem Gamblers: Missouri Data’ (2006) 22 Journal of Gambling Studies 1 pp 81–99

L Nower and A Blaszczynski ‘Characteristics of problem gamblers 56 years of age or older: A statewide study of casino self-excluders’ (2008) 23 Psychology and Aging 3 pp 577–584

S Pischke (2007) ‘Lecture Notes on Measurement Error’ Retrieved from

M Reeckman ‘Entwicklung des Spielbankenrechts in Deutschland von 2005 bis 2015‘ (2015) 15 Zeitschrift für Wett- Und Glücksspielrecht 6 pp 450–456

A Rhea ‘Voluntary Self Exclusion Lists: How They Work and Potential Problems’ (2005) 9 Gaming Law Review 5 pp 462–469

B Rush, S Veldhuizen and E Adlaf ‘Mapping the prevalence of problem gambling and its association with treatment accessibility and proximity to gambling venues’ (2007) 20 Journal of Gambling Issues 20 pp 193–213

Statistisches Bundesamt ‘Zensus 2011: Ausgewählte Ergebnisse‘ (Wiesbaden, 2013) Retrieved from

P Townshend ’Self-exclusion in a Public Health Environment: An Effective Treatment Option in New Zealand’ (2007) 5 International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction 4 pp 390–395

N Tremblay, C Boutin and R Ladouceur ‘Improved Self-exclusion Program: Preliminary Results’ (2008) 24 Journal of Gambling Studies 4 pp 505–518

M Tuncay ‘Glücksspielsucht unter türkischen Migranten‘ (Presentation at Arbeitskreis gegen Spielsucht e.V. Unna, 19.05.2016)

S D Vasiliadis, A C Jackson, D Christensen and K Francis ‘Physical accessibility of gaming opportunity and its relationship to gaming involvement and problem gambling: A systematic review’ (2013) Journal of Gambling Issues 28 pp 1-46

R A Volberg, M W Abbott, S Rönnberg and I M E Munck (2001) ‘Prevalence and risks of pathological gambling in Sweden’ (2001) 104 Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 4 pp 250-256

J W Welte, G M Barnes, M-C O Tidwell, J H Hoffman and W F Wieczorek ’The Relationship Between Distance from Gambling Venues and Gambling Participation and Problem Gambling Among U.S. Adults’ (2016) 32 Journal of Gambling Studies 4 pp 1055–1063

J W Welte, G M Barnes, W F Wieczorek and M C Tidwell ‘Gambling participation and pathology in the United States - A sociodemographic analysis using classification trees’ (2004) 29 Addictive Behaviors 5 pp 983–989